LettersRep. Gabrielle Giffords has seen what has happened to her House and Senate colleagues over the past week at health-care town hall meetings across the country and she’s hunkering down. Some would say she’s hiding. Giffords cancelled public appearances Thursday at American Legion Post #66 in Sahuarita and at Pima Community College, and announced that she has combined and moved them to a heavily secured Air Force base. Probably because it’s trickier for protesters to get past soldiers with guns. Giffords’ communications director insists that combining the appearances — during which she’ll talk about the new GI Bill — was necessary because of growing interest that required a bigger venue. Baloney. (And that’s putting it kindly.) This same staff member said Giffords had no public health-care forums planned despite questions and confusion among constituents that is growing by the hour. Then he said Giffords couldn’t possibly schedule a health-care town hall now because it takes a lot of time to line up a venue and the staff to make it happen. That’s an odd statement given that they secured the auditorium at Davis-Monthan AFB virtually on a moment’s notice. To be sure, Giffords hasn’t escaped without bruises in all of this. She was met with shouts in Douglas a week ago during a “Congress on Your Corner” event at a grocery store, and protesters have targeted her in Sierra Vista and Tucson in the past week. What do they want? Answers. Her official response: “Southern Arizonans want a civil discussion on reforming our health insurance system, and we must call for an immediate end to the manipulation and misleading statements by outside special interest groups. We deserve a full and honest debate on this critical issue.” We sure do, so let’s start talking. I’m guessing just about any school in Congressional District 8 (or any of several rec centers in Green Valley) would be eager to host a town hall meeting on short notice. (And, I should add, if a member of Congress has trouble booking a hall in the face of the most high-profile matter in the country, we’re all in trouble.) But the fact is Giffords doesn’t want to talk to you right now. Maybe next month when things blow over. It’s understandable, of course. How much real work can get done amid angry shouts and sign-waving — she said just that a week ago in Sierra Vista. But Giffords needs to remember that anger stems from frustration, and frustration manifests itself in what should be interpreted as nothing less than a demand for answers and dialogue. So here’s or proposal: Come to Green Valley. We’ll book the venue, and promise the exchange will be civil and informative. The local radio station, KGVY, has even offered to stream it live from another location if that makes Giffords more comfortable. But come. And help us all make sense of this. — Dan Shearer
Article RatingReader Comments
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the view of gvnews.com. Jfrom SV wrote on Aug 13, 2009 12:09 AM: " She wont answer you, Dan. I've asked her three pressing questions by e-mail and she wont even answer that way. I think the reason they don't respond is because they don't know what to say!!! ---or they don't know what they are permitted to say. " Merv Johnson wrote on Aug 13, 2009 9:04 AM: " "What do they want? Answers." Actually, no. They already have all the answers, except the answer to how to fix health care. What they want is to scream and shout and drown out rational discussion. You're deluded. " Lindsay wrote on Aug 13, 2009 9:42 AM: " let's see...Shouting mobs preventing the civil exchange of ideas...Loaded weapons being carried and/or dropped into "Townhall Meetings"..."Death Panels"...Is it any wonder that Democratic candidates are moving toward caution in engaging possibly irrational constutuents? And, REALLY, Mr. Shearer, "hiding from Green Valley"? Are you unable to travel to Tucson and Davis-Monthan Air Force Base? " Bernard Thomas wrote on Aug 13, 2009 12:30 PM: " Anyone interested in the health care debate can get more information on the internet than from these live "events". People want the Congresswoman live so they can shout at her and "demonstrate". I don't blame her for refusing to play that game. If anybody wants her to know their opinion, send her an email or write her a letter. " Johnny Ringo wrote on Aug 13, 2009 6:09 PM: " These people complaining about the shouting have no problem with the thugs at ACORN and SEIU or with conservative speakers being shouted down at colleges. They are frauds who only want their side heard. The scum throwing pies at Ann Coulter are not irrational to the left wing nut jobs. They were just "expressing" themselves. The leftist morons outside the Republican Convention was all OK. Giffords was hiding from GV. Not many people are going to go to Tucson to hear her especially when they know the program is fixed. At DM? Really? You nailed it Dan and it is time for Giffords to be replaced. " ba wrote on Aug 14, 2009 7:35 PM: " The protesters don't want answers. Tha'ts just a simplistic way of trying to give the Fright Wing their day in the spotlight. They want to yell and repeat crap about death panels and Hitler. Watch the news reports and see if any of these people have actually listened for answers. How about the GV News try to be fair and impartial. " Dwight H. wrote on Aug 15, 2009 10:03 AM: " Instead of fueling the fires of the ill-informed, it seems the GVNews could do a little simple investigation of its own to debunk some of the stupid myths and outright lies being directed at the issues involving health care reform. A little responsible journalism, please? " Submit a Comment |
Today's Weather
Green Valley, AZ
sponsored by: ![]() Top Menus |
Copyright © 2010 Green Valley News and Sun - All right Reserved
About Us / Subscriptions / Contact Us / Advertise with us / User Agreement / HUD rules / Make us your home page
About Us / Subscriptions / Contact Us / Advertise with us / User Agreement / HUD rules / Make us your home page

Please visit our 



George Johnson wrote on Aug 12, 2009 5:11 PM:
Thank you for asking her to come to Green Valley. "